A client tells you that your law firm made a mistake.
Does that mean you have a legal malpractice claim?
Not necessarily.
A client complaint, an allegation of an error and a formal malpractice claim are not always the same thing. However, for a law firm owner, what happens next can be important.
Professional liability insurance policies can contain specific requirements for reporting claims and circumstances that could potentially lead to claims. Waiting until a lawsuit is filed to understand those requirements can create problems.
Law firm owners should have a process for identifying potential issues, documenting what happened and determining when the firm’s professional liability insurer or insurance advisor should become involved.
Start by Understanding What the Client Is Alleging
Not every unhappy client is alleging legal malpractice.
A client may be dissatisfied with the outcome of a case, frustrated with communication or unhappy about how long something took. In other situations, the client may believe that something the attorney did or failed to do caused financial harm.
When a concern is raised, the firm should first understand what actually happened.
Review the file, communications, deadlines and other relevant documentation. Determine which attorneys or employees were involved and what information is available.
The goal at this stage isn’t for the law firm owner to immediately determine whether malpractice occurred.
It is to understand the situation well enough to determine what should happen next.
Document Potential Errors Inside the Law Firm
Law firms should also have an internal process for attorneys and employees to raise potential mistakes.
Consider an associate who realizes a deadline may have been missed or discovers an issue with work previously provided to a client.
The owner shouldn’t have to learn about that problem months later when the client makes a demand.
Internal reporting gives the firm an opportunity to understand the issue earlier, preserve relevant documentation and determine whether additional action is necessary.
As a law firm grows beyond the founding attorney, this process becomes increasingly important because the owner will no longer have direct knowledge of every matter.
Review Your Professional Liability Policy’s Reporting Requirements
Attorney professional liability insurance is generally written on a claims-made basis.
That makes timing important.
Policies may contain provisions explaining when a claim must be reported and how the policy treats circumstances that could reasonably be expected to result in a future claim.
The specific requirements depend on the policy.
This is why law firm owners shouldn’t assume that the insurance conversation begins only after receiving a lawsuit.
If a client alleges an error or the firm becomes aware of a significant potential problem, review the policy and determine whether the circumstances trigger a reporting requirement.
The question isn’t only:
“Have we been sued?”
It may also be:
“Has something happened that our policy requires us to report?”
Reporting a Potential Claim Is Not an Admission of Liability
Law firm owners can sometimes be hesitant to report a situation because they haven’t determined whether the attorney actually did anything wrong.
Those are separate issues.
Reporting a claim or potential circumstance according to the terms of an insurance policy doesn’t mean the firm is admitting liability to the client.
It allows the insurer to evaluate the situation and determine what involvement may be appropriate under the policy.
Depending on the circumstances, the carrier may request documentation or additional information and provide direction regarding the next steps.
Understanding that process before a problem occurs can make the situation much easier to manage.
Be Careful About Resolving the Problem Before Reviewing the Policy
Attorneys spend their careers solving problems, so an owner’s first instinct may be to immediately resolve a client complaint.
That could mean offering a refund, agreeing to reimburse an expense, promising to correct something or making other commitments to the client.
Before taking those steps, review the firm’s professional liability policy.
Policies can contain provisions related to voluntary payments, cooperation, defense and settlements. Taking action without understanding those provisions could affect how the insurance company responds later.
This doesn’t mean the firm should stop communicating with the client.
It means the owner should recognize when a client-service issue may have developed into a professional liability issue requiring a different process.
What Happens After a Legal Malpractice Claim Is Reported?
The exact claims process will depend on the circumstances and the professional liability policy.
If a covered claim progresses, the insurance company may become involved in defending the firm according to the policy terms.
This is when several provisions within an attorney malpractice policy become particularly important.
Law firm owners should understand questions such as:
Do defense costs reduce the policy limit?
Does the deductible apply to defense expenses?
How are defense counsel and legal expenses handled?
What role does the firm have in settlement decisions?
Does the policy include a consent-to-settle provision?
Is there a hammer clause that could affect the firm’s financial responsibility if it refuses a recommended settlement?
These details can affect how much protection remains available and how much control the law firm maintains during the claims process.
They are worth understanding when purchasing the policy rather than discovering them for the first time during a claim.
Build Your Law Firm’s Claims Process Before You Need It
Professional liability risk management goes beyond purchasing malpractice insurance.
A law firm should know how potential problems will be identified and escalated.
Consider establishing a process that answers:
Who should an associate or employee contact if they believe a mistake occurred?
How should the issue be documented?
Who reviews the matter?
Who has access to the firm’s professional liability policy?
Who contacts the firm’s insurance advisor or carrier?
How are relevant client files and communications preserved?
The goal isn’t to turn every client complaint into an insurance claim.
It is to make sure potential issues reach the right people early enough for the firm to make an informed decision.
Law Firm Owners Need a Process, Not an Immediate Verdict
When a client says your law firm made a mistake, your first responsibility as the owner isn’t to immediately decide whether malpractice occurred.
Understand the allegation. Review and preserve the documentation. Identify who was involved. Review the firm’s reporting obligations. Bring in the appropriate advisors when necessary.
Professional liability insurance can transfer some of the financial risk associated with defending and resolving covered malpractice claims.
But insurance works best as part of a larger risk-management process.
For attorneys leaving Big Law to build their own firms, that’s one more responsibility that may previously have existed somewhere else inside the organization.
Now it belongs to the firm you’re building.
Leaving Big Law to start your own firm? Schedule a conversation with The Bunker to review the risks your insurance program is designed to address.
